In the Corner with Dan Hughes
169-150212 In the Treasure Corner - Counterfeit, or What?

The San Francisco mint, 1917.

Somebody was doing SOMETHING unauthorized with one of the new machines that made half dollars, and there were no clues as to who (or what?) was responsible.  The Secret Service to the rescue...

This is the exciting story of a counterfeiter who didn't really counterfeit - or did he?  See what you think, as you listen to the story of Charlie Butler and the absolutely-perfect fifty-cent pieces he made on the sly.


For more free articles and a look at (okay, an ad for) my book, The Metal Detecting Manual, visit

Direct download: 169counterfeit1917S.mp3
Category:treasure -- posted at: 9:25pm CDT

  • fascinating. I had not heard that story before. And you're right, by any normal legal definition he was not counterfeiting. As you point out, he was definitely misappropriating government property. And if he had been printing currency rather than minting silver halves, it is possible that he could have run foul of monetization laws.

    posted by: Paul Taylor on 2015-02-13 17:45:56

Post your comment:


E-mail (will not be published)


Your Comment

Please do not click submit more than once.